Squidward Tentacles
Squidward Tentacles worked his way through dance school.  Cashier at the Krusty Krab by day, interpretive dancer at night.  His talents have been seldom recognized and his passion for the performing arts trounced more than once.  His favorite styles include waltz, swing, and ballet. 
 
Squidward may prove to be this hand's wildcard.  Giving perhaps more praise than punishment.  He'll be watching the overall performance and making his decisions based on that.  Squidward may not dock points for deviations from the routine if they are pulled off well enough.  On the same token however, his criticisms may be the harshest.  Squidward like the rest of the judges isn't one to pull punches.